Renovating or building a home? One major decision you’ll face is choosing between plaster and drywall for your walls. Both materials have pros and cons, and the right choice depends on your budget, home style, and long-term needs.

Here are the key differences, advantages, and drawbacks of both options. By the end, you’ll have a clear idea of which material suits your home best.

What’s the Difference Between Plaster and Drywall?

Plaster Walls

Plaster has been used for centuries. It involves applying layers of wet plaster over wooden laths or metal mesh, creating a durable and solid wall surface.

Pros of Plaster Walls:

1. Durability – Plaster walls last for decades without cracks or damage.

2. Soundproofing – Offers excellent noise insulation.

3. Aesthetic Appeal – Smooth, elegant finish ideal for period homes.

4. Fire Resistance – More fire-resistant than drywall.

Cons of Plaster Walls:

1. Higher Cost – Labour-intensive process makes it more expensive.

2. Time-Consuming Installation – Takes longer to dry and finish.

3. Difficult Repairs – Fixing cracks can be tricky.

Drywall (Plasterboard) Walls

Drywall is a modern alternative, made of gypsum sandwiched between paper sheets. It is quicker and cheaper to install compared to plaster.

Pros of Drywall Walls:

1. Affordable – Lower cost compared to plaster.

2. Faster Installation – Can be put up in hours, not days.

3. Easy to Repair – Simple patching and repainting.

4. Energy Efficient – Offers good insulation.

Cons of Drywall Walls:

1. Less Durable – Prone to dents and damage.

2. Lower Soundproofing – Doesn’t block noise as well as plaster.

3. Not as Fire-Resistant – Plaster provides better fire protection.

Which One is Best for Your Home?

1. Are You Restoring a Period Property?

Go for Plaster – If you have a historic Norfolk home, plaster will maintain its classic charm. Many old homes were built with lath and plaster walls, and replacing them with drywall can lower property value.

2. Are You on a Tight Budget?

Choose Drywall – If cost is a major factor, drywall is the better choice. On average, plaster installation can cost up to 50% more than drywall.

3. Do You Want a Highly Durable Wall?

Plaster Wins – If you want a long-lasting, impact-resistant wall, plaster is the way to go. It is less likely to get holes or dents compared to drywall.

4. Do You Need Quick Installation?

Pick Drywall – If you’re in a hurry to finish your project, drywall is the best option. It can be installed in a day, while plaster may take several days to cure properly.

5. Are You Looking for Better Soundproofing?

Plaster is Superior – For homeowners who want peace and quiet, plaster is a great option as it absorbs sound better than drywall.

Cost Comparison: Plaster vs. Drywall in Norfolk

Here’s a rough estimate of costs for installing plaster and drywall in the UK:

Pros and Cons at a Glance

Plaster

 ✅ Long-lasting and durable
✅ Elegant, smooth finish
✅ Great soundproofing
❌ Expensive
❌ Takes longer to install
❌ Difficult to repair

Drywall

 ✅ Budget-friendly
✅ Quick and easy to install
✅ Easy to repair
❌ Less durable
❌ Prone to dents and damage
❌ Not as soundproof

Expert Tips for Choosing the Right Material

For Homeowners in Norfolk

1. Traditional Homes: Choose plaster to maintain historic charm.

2. Modern Builds: Go for drywall to save time and money.

3. High-Traffic Areas: Use plaster for durability.

4. Bedrooms & Living Rooms: Drywall works fine in these areas.

5. Budget Constraints: Drywall is the more cost-effective choice.

Conclusion: What’s Right for You?

Still unsure whether to choose plaster or drywall? Here’s a simple rule:

1. If you prioritise durability, soundproofing, and a premium finish, plaster is the best option.

2. If you want a cost-effective, quick, and easy-to-maintain wall, drywall is your go-to choice.

Need help with plastering or drywall installation in Norfolk? Contact ELV Plastering today for expert advice and a free quote!